“Cambio, cambio.” Beneath the scorching heat, dozens of currency traders are hawking American currency along Florida Street, a lively pedestrian strip in Buenos Aires. Referred to as arbolitos (“little trees”), they are thriving before the October 26 midterm elections in a nation accustomed to holding the US dollar.
“The best time to buy is currently,” says a arbolito, refusing to provide her name. “[The dollar] dropped a little but it’s deceptive – it will rebound.”
Like her, economists from all backgrounds expect a depreciation of the national currency once the election is over. The president has imposed a cap on the currency to control soaring price increases and now it remains overvalued and reserves are depleted, causing the national economy sluggish as buyers opt for low-cost foreign goods.
Fertile Ground
The nation is a very special case. Argentina has frequently been racked by sovereign defaults and financial turmoil and the electorate have been susceptible over the years to leftwing populism, in the form of the influential Peronist movement, and now the president’s rightwing version.
Milei is a textbook populist: captivating, unconventional, vowing forceful policies to wrestle back control of the economy from traditional elites on behalf of ordinary citizens.
These defining traits are shared by his ally to the north, as well as Nigel Farage, who styles himself as a beer-drinking champion of the common man despite being a privately educated ex-finance professional.
Up until lately, the president’s strategy – including widespread sell-offs and deep public spending cuts – had won plaudits from international lenders for helping to control inflation in check. The programme shares similarities with the policies of his political hero Margaret Thatcher, who also saw rising prices as a monster to be slain, no matter the cost.
However investors began losing confidence in Milei’s radical project lately after a shaky result in local polls and a series of corruption scandals. Only massive financial intervention from abroad has prevented what looked set to become a full-blown currency crisis.
Contradictions
The 2016 referendum several years ago likely contained similar reasoning, and its leader, Boris Johnson, swept away doubts about economic detail with a bullish determination to implement the “will of the people” in the face of the establishment’s horror.
The Reform leader to date committed few policies in writing except for a call for large-scale removals, that he later appeared to revise on the hoof. He aims to curb the Bank of England, possibly replacing its head, the incumbent, with distrust of a stodgy establishment as a central element of populist rhetoric.
His fiscal plans appear to be in flux: concerned about facing criticism for proposing reckless spending, he recently abandoned a pledge for significant tax cuts. His second-in-command, Richard Tice, said they would focus instead on reductions in government expenditure.
The opposition hopes this stance will enable it to portray Farage as planning to reintroduce fiscal tightening – an argument the chancellor has made repeatedly, contrasting it with her strategy of increasing public investment.
An economics professor says there exist inconsistencies within the populist platform, as it stands. “The party is funded by affluent backers demanding tax cuts and reduced rules, but also emphasizing the complaints of ordinary workers and the decline in manufacturing employment,” he explains. “There is a conflict here among wealthy supporters seeking radical free-market policies, and this narrative of restoring UK employment and industrial revival.”
Maintaining Control
In truth, the evidence indicates populists of any stripe often perform poorly when faced with real-world challenges (although each charismatic individual claims to offer something unique).
A recent paper from a leading journal analysed the outcomes of 51 populist presidents and prime ministers, over more than a century. The study revealed typically, over the long term, gross domestic product per head tends to be 10% lower in nations run by populist rulers compared to similar economies under conventional leadership.
“Financial decline, weakening economic fundamentals and the decay of governance typically go hand in hand with populist rule,” contend the paper’s authors.
Another intriguing finding from the study, though, is even with their negative impacts, populist figures are often effective at holding on to power, remaining in power for eight years, compared with shorter tenures for their more moderate equivalents.
In other words, it is not clear whether even if their policies fail, populists face immediate consequences at the ballot box. Like the Brexiters’ promise to regain sovereignty, their attraction reaches beyond everyday financial matters.
Yet returning to Buenos Aires, regardless of if the government’s agenda fails or is sustained by external aid, Argentina’s citizens have already paid significant costs.